Gold bought and sold 30 months apart. Long-term?

Yes — gold is long-term after 24 months

No — gold is always short-term

Shares in a private company that is not listed anywhere, held 20 months.

Short-term — unlisted assets need 24 months

Long-term — all shares are on the 12-month clock

Long-term — 20 months is more than a year

Lesson 1 of 3 · 8 min

Two clocks, and nothing else decides it

Whether a gain is short-term or long-term now comes down to two holding periods: twelve months and twenty-four. Which one applies depends on one question.

Two people sell the same fund on the same day for the same profit and pay different tax. Nothing about the fund explains it. What explains it is how long each of them held it — and the number of months that counts is not the same for every kind of asset.

Before 2024 there were three clocks — 12, 24 and 36 months — and which one applied depended on a list you had to look up. The Finance (No. 2) Act 2024 cut it to two. For all listed securities the period is 12 months. For everything else it is 24 months. That is the whole rule now.

What changed, and what did not

One group moved. Bonds, debentures and gold came down from a 36-month clock to a 24-month one; the listed-equity clock did not change.
Asset	Long-term after	Was
Listed equity shares	12 months	12 months — unchanged
Units of an equity-oriented fund	12 months	12 months — unchanged
Bonds, debentures, gold	24 months	36 months
Unlisted shares	24 months	24 months — unchanged
Immovable property — land or a building	24 months	24 months — unchanged

Myth

“Gold has to be held for three years before it counts as long-term.”

False

That was the rule, and it is the one most people still repeat. The holding period for gold, bonds and debentures came down from 36 months to 24. Someone applying the old number to a sale would classify their own gain wrongly.

So is a short-term gain the bad one?

KabirTara

Kabirasking
Short-term sounds like the one you want to avoid. Should I just hold everything past the line?
Taraexplaining
Careful. That is a tax fact turning into a plan, and the two are different things. The tax rate is one input into a decision. What the money is for, and when you need it, are usually bigger ones.
Kabirasking
But holding one more month could genuinely cost less tax.
Taraexplaining
It could. It could also cost more if the price falls in that month, and nobody knows which. What this course can give you is the ability to work out what you owe. It cannot tell you when to sell, and anyone who says otherwise is selling something.

Quick check

You bought gold 30 months ago and sold it yesterday. Short-term or long-term?

Check yourself

1 / 3

Kabir asks

How many holding-period clocks are there now?

Done reading?

Saved in this browser.